Procurement vs. Sourcing: What's the Difference?

Procurement vs. sourcing comes down to scope. Sourcing is the part of procurement that decides who you buy from and on what terms: finding suppliers, comparing them, negotiating and signing the contract. Procurement is the whole cycle around it, from the moment someone needs something to the moment the supplier is paid and the records are filed. Every sourcing decision sits inside procurement, but most procurement work happens after sourcing is done.

The difference matters for one practical reason. Sourcing sets the price and terms. Procurement decides whether the organization actually gets them.

What is sourcing?

Sourcing is the process of finding, evaluating and selecting suppliers for a product or service, then agreeing on price, terms and service levels in a contract. It answers one question: who should we buy this from, and on what terms?

A typical sourcing project runs in this order:

1. Define the need. Specifications, volumes, service levels and who will use it.
2. Research the market. Which suppliers can meet the need, and how pricing usually works in the category.
3. Ask for information or bids. A request for information (RFI) to learn about suppliers, then a request for proposal (RFP) or request for quote (RFQ) to compare offers.
4. Evaluate. Score responses on total cost, quality, service, risk and fit.
5. Negotiate and award. Settle price, payment terms, rebates, delivery terms and performance measures, then sign.
6. Hand off. Give the people who place orders what they need to buy from the new contract.

Sourcing is periodic. A team sources a category when a contract is about to expire or a supplier fails. It also goes back out to bid when demand or the market has changed enough to matter.

Strategic sourcing vs. tactical sourcing

Strategic sourcing looks at a whole category over the long term. The team studies how much the organization spends, with whom and why. It groups demand across departments or sites and picks suppliers on total cost of ownership rather than the lowest unit price. It also plans how the supplier relationship will be managed after the contract is signed.

Tactical sourcing is short-term and reactive: finding a supplier for an immediate need, usually on price alone. It is faster and needs less analysis, which makes it a sensible choice for one-off or low-value purchases. Used for recurring spend, it tends to cost more over time, because each purchase is negotiated on its own and the organization never uses its full volume.

Dryden's strategic sourcing services cover the strategic side for indirect spend categories.

What is procurement?

Procurement is the full process an organization uses to get the goods and services it needs: identifying the need, deciding how to buy, buying, receiving, paying and keeping records. Sourcing is one stage of it.

A common way to lay out the procurement cycle:

1. Need identified. A department needs something new or needs to restock.
2. Requisition. The requester submits what they need and why.
3. Approval. A manager or budget holder approves the spend.
4. Source, or buy from a contract. If a contract already covers the item, the buyer orders from it. If not, the need goes to sourcing.
5. Purchase order. The PO is issued to the supplier.
6. Receipt. Goods or services arrive and are checked.
7. Three-way match. The PO, the receiving record and the supplier's invoice are compared. Quantities and prices should agree.
8. Payment. Accounts payable pays the invoice.
9. Records. The documents are kept for reporting and audit.

The requisition and approval, plus steps 5 through 8, are often called procure-to-pay. Procurement also covers the work around the cycle: purchasing policy, supplier performance, contract renewals and spend reporting.

Procurement vs. sourcing: side by side

The difference between sourcing and procurement is easiest to see next to purchasing, the third term people mix up with both.

Where purchasing and accounts payable fit

Purchasing is the transactional part of procurement. A buyer turns an approved requisition into a purchase order, follows the order, confirms receipt and resolves problems with the supplier. Many organizations use "purchasing" and "procurement" as if they mean the same thing. The useful line between them: procurement includes deciding what to buy and from whom, and purchasing carries out the order.

Accounts payable sits at the end. AP pays the supplier once the invoice agrees with the purchase order and the receiving record. That three-way match is the last point where a price that has drifted from the contract can be caught. If the PO itself carries the wrong price, the match passes and the overcharge gets paid.

Who does what: sourcing manager, procurement manager, buyer

• Sourcing manager (often called a category manager). Owns one or more spend categories, runs market research, RFPs and negotiations, and holds the supplier relationship at the contract level.
• Procurement manager. Owns the process: policies, approval rules, systems, supplier performance reviews and reporting. In larger organizations this role sits over both sourcing and purchasing.
• Buyer or purchasing agent. Places and manages individual orders, usually against contracts the sourcing team has already set up.

In a small organization, or a small purchasing office at a college, one person often does all three. That works as long as they know which job they are doing at any moment. Running a proper sourcing event takes different time and skills than clearing the day's purchase orders.

Why the difference matters: savings are won in sourcing and lost in procurement

A sourcing team can negotiate a good contract and still see little of its value. That happens when the procurement side does not keep spending on the agreed terms. Common leaks:

• Off-contract buying. People order from a familiar supplier, a website or a purchasing card instead of the contracted supplier.
• Price drift. Catalog or invoice prices move away from the contract price list, and nobody compares the two.
• Missed rebates and credits. Volume rebates, early-payment discounts or service credits written into the contract are never claimed.
• Silent renewals. A contract rolls over on old terms because nobody tracked the date.
• Specification creep. Departments order premium items when the contract was priced on standard ones.

None of these show up in the sourcing results. They show up later, in the spend data and the invoices.

Two kinds of work find them. A spend analysis shows how much spend actually goes through contracts, and with which suppliers. A contract-compliance audit checks invoices line by line against contract terms and recovers overcharges from suppliers. Our guide to the procurement audit explains how those audits work.

A worked example: one category from start to finish

Take janitorial supplies at a mid-sized university. Several departments and campus buildings buy cleaning products, paper goods and trash liners on their own, from different suppliers.

Sourcing

1. The procurement office pulls a year of spend data and finds the same items bought from several suppliers at different prices.
2. It combines that demand into one category and runs an RFP with a defined product list and expected volumes.
3. It awards a contract with a fixed price list, a date for reviewing price changes, delivery terms and a volume rebate.

Procurement

4. The contract price list goes into the purchasing system as a catalog, and departments are told to order from it.
5. Buyers issue POs against the contract. Purchasing-card use for these items is restricted.
6. Accounts payable matches each invoice to its PO and receiving record.
7. Each quarter, someone compares invoice prices to the contract price list, checks that the rebate was paid and looks for orders placed outside the contract.

Steps 1 to 3 set the price. Steps 4 to 7 decide whether the university actually pays it. Skip steps 4 to 7 and the university ends up with a good contract that most departments don't use.

How this looks in higher education

Colleges and universities often have a capable sourcing function and a loose procurement one. Buying authority is spread across departments, labs and campuses, and purchasing cards make small orders easy to place outside any contract. The result is a contract that looks good on paper and a spend report that shows many suppliers for the same items.

Grant-funded buying adds rules. When purchases are made with federal grant funds, the procurement standards in the federal Uniform Guidance (2 CFR 200.317 to 200.327) apply. Section 200.318 requires documented procurement procedures, oversight of contractors, and records that show the procurement method, how the contractor was selected and the basis for the price. That puts weight on both halves: the sourcing decision has to be documented, and the procurement side has to keep the records.

For more on how Dryden works with colleges and universities, see higher education procurement consulting or our post on strategic sourcing for educational institutions.

Common questions

Is sourcing the same as procurement?

No. Sourcing is one stage of procurement: finding, evaluating and contracting with suppliers. Procurement covers the whole cycle, including requisitions, approvals, purchase orders, receiving, invoice matching, payment and records. Smaller organizations often give both jobs to one person, but the activities are still different.

What is the difference between sourcing and purchasing?

Sourcing decides which supplier to use and sets the price and terms, usually through an RFP or a negotiation. Purchasing places and manages individual orders under those terms. Sourcing happens from time to time for each category. Purchasing happens every day, one order at a time.

Is strategic sourcing the same as procurement?

No. Strategic sourcing is a long-term, data-led way of running the sourcing stage: analyzing spend, combining demand and choosing suppliers on total cost. Procurement is the wider function. It includes strategic sourcing plus purchasing, supplier management, policy and payment.

Who should own sourcing in a small organization?

Usually the person who already manages procurement, working with the budget holders who use the category. The important part is protecting time for sourcing. If a category only gets sourced after its contract has already expired, the work turns into tactical buying.

Getting both halves right

Dryden Group is a procurement consulting firm based in Radnor, PA. Since 2001 we have worked with universities, hospitals and health systems, state, county and local governments, and businesses in every industry, including global Fortune 1000 companies. Our work covers both halves of this article: strategic sourcing to set the right terms, and spend analysis and procurement audits to check that those terms hold. If you'd like a second look at either, contact us.

Related service: Strategic Sourcing →