
Should Cost Model vs. Landed Cost: How to Calculate Each
A should cost model estimates what an item ought to cost, built up from its cost elements: materials, labor, overhead and a reasonable profit. A landed cost model adds up what a purchase costs once it reaches you: the price plus freight, insurance, duties and fees. Should cost tests whether a price is fair. Landed cost shows what you pay.
The two models answer different questions, so buyers often use both. Many should cost models stop at the supplier's dock, and a landed cost model carries the price from there to yours. Total cost of ownership adds what an item costs to run and dispose of.
Below are the formulas, worked examples and a guide to when each check is worth the effort. For catalog items, comparing the price with what other buyers pay is often enough.
Should cost vs. landed cost at a glance
Should cost, landed cost and total cost of ownership each answer a different question about the same purchase.
| Should cost model | Landed cost model | Total cost of ownership | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Question it answers | Is the supplier's price fair? | What does the purchase cost by the time it arrives? | What will the item cost over its whole life? |
| Starts from | The item's cost elements | The supplier's price | The landed cost |
| Adds | Overhead, sales and administrative costs, and profit | Freight, insurance, duties, import fees, brokerage and handling | Running, maintenance, downtime and disposal costs |
| Best for | Custom or engineered items, sole-source contracts, price increases you can't check | Imports, and any order with significant freight or fees | Equipment and other items with long lives and running costs |
| Data you need | Specifications, material prices, labor rates, process times | Quotes, freight rates, duty rates, fee schedules | Usage, maintenance and energy records, expected life |
| Main limit | Takes time and expertise, and the result is an estimate | Some costs aren't known until the goods arrive | Rests on assumptions about the future |
What is a should cost model?
A should cost model is a bottom-up estimate of what an item ought to cost to make and sell, built from its cost elements rather than from the supplier's price. Should cost analysis, should cost modeling and should costing all describe the same work: estimate the cost, compare it with the quote and ask about the gap. Cost modeling in general means estimating a cost from its drivers, such as quantities, rates and times.
The term has a formal meaning in US government contracting. The Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) calls a should-cost review "a specialized form of cost analysis." Such reviews "do not assume that a contractor's historical costs reflect efficient and economical operation" (48 CFR 15.407-4).
Instead, should-cost reviews examine how efficiently the contractor uses its workforce, methods, materials and equipment. A should cost model in business works the same way. It prices the item as an efficient supplier would make it, not as the current supplier says it does.
In UK central government the term is broader. Cabinet Office guidance uses "Should Cost Model" as "the term used in the Sourcing Playbook and the Construction Playbook to describe whole life cost modelling" (guidance note, May 2021). That meaning overlaps with total cost of ownership, covered further down.

What goes into a should cost model
| Cost element | What it covers | Where the numbers come from |
|---|---|---|
| Materials | Raw materials and bought-in parts, with an allowance for scrap | The specification or bill of materials, priced from commodity indexes and recent quotes |
| Direct labor | Hours to make, assemble or deliver the item, at a wage rate that includes benefits | Process time estimates, and wage data such as the Bureau of Labor Statistics' occupational wage estimates |
| Overhead | Machines, energy, tooling, supervision and the building | A rate per machine hour, or a percentage of labor |
| Sales, general and administrative costs (SG&A) | The supplier's office, sales and management costs | A percentage of cost, based on similar suppliers |
| Packaging and freight | Packing, and delivery if the quote includes it | Carrier rates, or a landed cost model (below) |
| Profit | The supplier's return | Typical margins in the supplier's industry; a listed company's annual report shows its operating margin |
For a service, such as custodial or security staffing, labor and benefits make up most of the model and materials are small.
How to calculate should cost
To calculate should cost, add up the cost elements, then add a profit that is reasonable for the supplier's industry.
Total cost = materials + direct labor + overhead + SG&A (+ packaging and freight, if the quote is delivered)
Should cost = total cost ÷ (1 - target profit margin)
If your profit figure is a markup on cost instead, multiply: should cost = total cost × (1 + markup).
Margin or markup?
Margin and markup are easy to confuse, and the difference changes the answer. A margin is profit as a share of the selling price. A markup is profit as a share of cost. A 20% margin is the same as a 25% markup.
Take $2,500 of cost and a 20% margin. The should cost is $2,500 ÷ (1 - 0.20) = $3,125. Treating the 20% as a markup gives $2,500 × 1.20 = $3,000.
Dividing by the margin itself, $2,500 ÷ 0.20, gives $12,500, five times the cost. An earlier version of this article printed that formula next to the $3,125 result. The formulas above are the corrected ones.
Should cost model example
The worked example below builds a should cost model for one custom item: a steel equipment cart, ordered in a batch of 50. The figures are illustrations, not market data.
| Cost element | Basis | Per cart |
|---|---|---|
| Materials | Steel, casters and hardware, including scrap | $150.00 |
| Direct labor | 2.5 hours at $40 an hour, benefits included | $100.00 |
| Overhead | 50% of direct labor | $50.00 |
| SG&A | 10% of the costs above | $30.00 |
| Total cost | $330.00 | |
| Profit | 15% margin: $330 ÷ 0.85, less cost | $58.24 |
| Should cost | $388.24 |
The supplier quotes $460 a cart, about 18% above the should cost. The gap is $71.76 a cart, or $3,588 on the order.
Treat the gap as a reason to ask questions, not as proof of overcharging. Ask the supplier to walk through its price element by element: the steel gauge and weight, the labor hours, the overhead rate and the margin. Each answer either corrects your model or gives you a point to negotiate.
How to build a should cost model in six steps
- Define the item and the volume. Fix the specification, the annual quantity and the order size. Volume changes setup costs per unit and the price breaks on materials.
- Break the item into cost elements. List the materials and parts, each process step and its labor, and the packaging and delivery.
- Price each element from independent data. Use commodity indexes, wage data, machine rates and your own past purchases rather than the supplier's figures.
- Add overhead, SG&A and profit. Use rates typical for the supplier's industry, and write down every assumption.
- Compare the result with the quote. Ask the supplier for a cost breakdown in the same format, so the two line up element by element.
- Negotiate, then update. Take the gaps into the negotiation, and refresh the model when material prices or wages move.
Match the effort to the purchase. The UK guidance puts it this way: "The complexity of an SCM should be proportional to and reflective of the complexity and criticality of what you are trying to source." A one-off, low-value purchase rarely justifies a detailed model.
When a should cost model is worth the effort
A should cost model is worth building when no market price can tell you whether a quote is fair. The FAR separates two ways of checking a price (48 CFR 15.404-1):
- Price analysis is "the process of examining and evaluating a proposed price without evaluating its separate cost elements and proposed profit." It compares the price with other quotes, past prices, published price lists or market data.
- Cost analysis is "the review and evaluation of any separate cost elements and profit or fee" in an offeror's proposal. A should cost model is a form of cost analysis.
For government programs, the FAR says a program should-cost review "should be considered," particularly for major systems, when these conditions hold (48 CFR 15.407-4, paragraph (b)(2)):
- Some initial production has already taken place.
- The contract will be awarded on a sole source basis.
- Substantial quantities of like items will be needed in future years.
- The items have a history of increasing costs.
- The work is defined well enough to analyze, and major changes are unlikely.
- There is time to plan and run the review, and people with the right skills are available.
The model text for the FAR overhaul keeps the same list, renumbered as section 15.405-4.
Outside government, should cost earns its effort on custom or engineered items and on large repeat volumes. It also suits sole-source buying, one of the six procurement methods, because there are no competing quotes to compare.
For catalog and contract items, such as MRO parts, lab supplies or office supplies, a market price exists, and a price benchmark answers the question faster than a cost model. Dryden's supplier and category benchmarking works this way. We take one supplier's or one category's contract and 12 to 24 months of invoice line items. We adjust them for unit of measure, pack size, specification, volume, freight, rebates and payment terms, then compare each price with market pricing.
What is a landed cost model?
Landed cost is the total cost of getting a purchase to your door: the supplier's price plus freight, insurance, customs duties, import fees, brokerage and handling. A landed cost model adds those costs up for each supplier. Compare suppliers on landed cost, because unit prices quoted on different delivery terms can't be compared directly.
A landed cost usually includes:
- Freight to the port, the main leg, and inland delivery to your site
- Insurance for the goods in transit
- Customs duty, set by the product's tariff classification and country of origin in the Harmonized Tariff Schedule of the United States
- Import fees, such as the US merchandise processing fee and, for cargo arriving by ship, the harbor maintenance fee
- Brokerage and handling: customs broker fees, port charges, storage and receiving
- Supplier charges outside the unit price, such as packaging, small-order fees and surcharges
The delivery terms in the quote decide which of these you pay. The Incoterms rules published by the International Chamber of Commerce clarify "the tasks, costs and risks involved in the delivery of goods from sellers to buyers." An EXW (ex works) price names a place of delivery, usually the supplier's own site. An FOB (free on board) price names the port of loading, and a DDP (delivered duty paid) price names your destination.
The further the named place is from your door, the more of the landed cost you add yourself. For production materials, inbound freight is usually counted in the materials' landed cost, as our guide to direct vs. indirect procurement explains.

How to calculate landed cost
Use this landed cost formula, then divide by the number of units:
Landed cost = purchase price + freight + insurance + duties and import fees + brokerage and handling
Landed cost per unit = landed cost ÷ number of units
Spread shared costs, such as the freight on one container, across the units by value, weight or volume. Use the same method for every supplier you compare.
Landed cost example: overseas or domestic supplier
A buyer needs 5,000 units of an item. An overseas supplier quotes $10.00 a unit at its port of loading (FOB), and a domestic distributor quotes $11.25 a unit, delivered. On unit price, the overseas quote looks about 11% cheaper.
All figures in the table are illustrations except the two fee rates, which come from the regulations.
| Cost line | Basis | Overseas supplier |
|---|---|---|
| Goods | 5,000 units at $10.00 | $50,000.00 |
| Ocean freight and origin charges | Illustrative | $2,400.00 |
| Cargo insurance | Illustrative | $150.00 |
| Customs duty | Illustrative rate of 5% of value | $2,500.00 |
| Merchandise processing fee | 0.3464% of value (19 CFR 24.23) | $173.20 |
| Harbor maintenance fee | 0.125% of value (19 CFR 24.24) | $62.50 |
| Customs broker | Illustrative | $300.00 |
| Inland freight from the port | Illustrative | $1,200.00 |
| Landed cost | $56,785.70 | |
| Per unit | $11.36 |
The domestic quote comes to $56,250, or $11.25 a unit. Once landed, the overseas supplier costs about 11 cents a unit more. That's before counting the cash tied up during weeks in transit, or the extra stock needed to cover a late shipment.
Formal entries pay the merchandise processing fee unless an exemption applies, within a minimum and maximum that can change each fiscal year. The harbor maintenance fee applies to commercial cargo unloaded from ships at the US ports listed in the regulation, also unless an exemption or special rule applies. Duty rates depend on classification and origin, and additional tariffs can change during a contract, so check the current rate before you compare.
Estimates and actual landed costs drift apart when freight rates move, goods are classified under a different tariff line or charges appear that weren't in the quote. After each shipment, compare the estimate with the broker's entry documents and the freight invoices.
Landed cost on domestic orders
Landed cost isn't only an import problem. Many indirect purchases come from domestic distributors, and the extra costs arrive as fees on the invoice:
- freight and fuel surcharges
- small-order or below-minimum fees
- hazardous-material, dry-ice and cold-chain charges on lab supplies
- expedite and rush fees
- restocking fees on returns
Distributor fees rarely show up in the unit price you compare, and they add up across thousands of small orders. Check whether your contract allows each one, and at what rate. If the contract sets a minimum order for free delivery, orders below it may carry a fee, so fewer, larger orders can cost less. In office supplies, lab supplies and other high-volume categories, a contract compliance audit checks each fee billed against what the contract permits.
Should cost model or total cost of ownership?
A should cost model tests the price, while total cost of ownership (TCO) counts everything an item costs over its life. US federal rules define the same idea as life-cycle cost: "the total cost to the Government of acquiring, operating, supporting, and (if applicable) disposing of the items being acquired" (48 CFR 7.101).
The three measures nest inside each other. Should cost is a fair price at the supplier's door. Landed cost adds what it takes to get the item to yours. TCO adds what it costs to own: maintenance, consumables, energy, downtime, staff time and disposal, less any resale value.
Printers are a common example. A printer with a low purchase price can cost more over five years than a more expensive model if its toner costs more per page or it needs more service. For equipment like that, compare TCO first, then test the price.
In UK central government the two ideas overlap. The Cabinet Office guidance quoted above says the key factor is whole life cost "and not the initial purchase price." A should cost model in a UK public tender may be a TCO model under another name.
Cost and price analysis in universities and public bodies
Universities, hospitals and local governments that spend federal awards already have to test prices. Under the Uniform Guidance, a recipient "must perform a cost or price analysis for every procurement transaction, including contract modifications, in excess of the simplified acquisition threshold." The same paragraph says that "as a starting point," the recipient "must make independent estimates before receiving bids or proposals" (2 CFR 200.324, paragraph (a)).
A should cost model is one way to build that independent estimate for a custom item or a service contract. For catalog goods, a price analysis against past prices or market data is usually enough. The same section also rules out the "cost plus a percentage of cost" and "percentage of construction costs" methods of contracting (paragraph (c)).
State law and institutional policy can be stricter than the federal rules, so check which rules apply to the money being spent. Our higher education page explains how we work with colleges and universities.
Common mistakes
- Dividing by the margin. Cost ÷ margin overstates the price several times over. Divide by (1 - margin), or multiply by (1 + markup).
- Comparing prices on different delivery terms. A factory-gate estimate or an FOB quote can't be compared with a delivered price until both are landed.
- Benchmarking against list prices. Compare with what buyers actually pay, after discounts and rebates.
- Leaving out fees. Surcharges, small-order fees and brokerage are easy to miss, and they add up.
- Treating the model as a demand. A should cost model is an estimate, so use its gaps to ask questions. The UK guidance says the model "will not normally be shared with bidders during dialogue/negotiation" and is used to inform the buyer's negotiating position.
- Letting the model go stale. Update it when material prices, wages or tariffs change.
Common questions
What is the difference between should cost and will cost?
Will cost and should cost are two estimates used in US defense programs. The will-cost estimate is "the official program position for budgeting, programming and reporting." The should-cost estimate is "an internal management tool for incentivizing performance," measured against the will-cost figure (Army News Service, June 2011). Put simply, will cost is what you expect to pay if nothing changes, and should cost is what an efficient supplier would charge.
What is the difference between should cost and zero-based costing?
Should costing estimates what a supplier's product or service ought to cost, to test the supplier's price. Zero-based costing, like zero-based budgeting, rebuilds your own costs from zero each period instead of adjusting last year's figures. Both start from the work rather than from history, but should costing looks at the supplier and zero-based costing looks at your own spending. Target costing is a third idea: a manufacturer starts from the price customers will pay, subtracts the margin it needs and designs the product to meet the cost that remains.
What is an example of cost-plus pricing?
Cost-plus pricing sets the price as the supplier's cost plus an agreed markup or fee. A supplier with $80,000 of costs and an agreed 10% markup charges $88,000. A fixed fee protects the buyer better, because a percentage markup pays the supplier more when costs rise. Under federal awards, the "cost plus a percentage of cost" method of contracting is not allowed (2 CFR 200.324(c)).
Do you need software to build a should cost model?
A should cost model for a simple item fits in a spreadsheet. The UK guidance notes that a very simple model "could be key cost drivers and assumptions captured in a spreadsheet." Dedicated cost-modeling software can help with complex manufactured parts, for example by estimating process costs from engineering drawings. The data and the assumptions matter more than the tool.
What is the difference between landed cost and standard cost?
Landed cost is what a purchase actually cost to bring in: the price plus freight, duties and fees. Standard cost is a planned cost per unit that a company sets in advance for budgeting and inventory, often based on the expected landed cost. The difference between the two shows up as a variance, which tells finance where buying cost more or less than planned.
Where Dryden fits
Dryden Group is a procurement consulting firm founded in 2001. Many of the categories we work in, such as MRO, lab supplies and office supplies, are bought from catalogs and contracts, where a market price exists. There, our benchmarking shows whether a supplier's prices are in line with the market. The benchmark can then become the evidence in a renegotiation with the supplier you keep.
Related service: Benchmarking →














